Cowards are cruel
Dateca. 1824–1828
abstractA composition written while a student at Dartmouth. In it, Mitchell concludes that cowardice is cruel in several contexts: if it leads a person to value their life above the general good; to murder and torture others to save their own lives; and to forsake their duty to "plant the standard of the Cross in the dark places of the earth."
RepositoryMcCord Stewart Museum
Call NumberMitchell Family Fonds P044/A,4.11
Access and Usage RightsCopyright © 2024 Trustees of Dartmouth College. Publicly accessible for non-commercial use: these pages may be freely searched and displayed, but permission must be received for subsequent distribution in print or electronically. Please see http://www.dartmouth.edu/~library/schcomm/copyright/rights.html for more information.
Cowards are cruel.
[pitiful], and benevolent, and unsparingly
praise the brave and magnanimous; they look
6 with disdain on the coward, (if not with detestation).
But while the poet tells us that cowards are cruel,
we cannot embrace the proposition as containing
a universal truth, as though there was a nec
essary and inseparable connection between
cowardice and cruelty. For it does not follow,
that because a person is subject to a habitual
timidity, and is totally destitute of that magni
nimity of soul, required to form the brave;
11
inhuman and unfeeling temper. Many persons
1 are to be met with, who
2 2 roick virtues, show themselves acquainted with the
2 exercise of compassion and benevolence. Yes, a person
may desert the rank of the army through fear, or fall back
8 2 in the day of battle; he may be too pusillanimous to
resent an
lest his eyes should meet with some ghastly spectre; and yet
not be callous to the woes of his fellow men, nor
indifferent towards the children of misfortune,
8 and
man is cruel, who values his own
general good, who is profuse of the lives of others to pre
serve his own, and forsakes the post, to which duty and
the publick interest, may well be regarded as guilty
8.1.2 of cruelty. Such a man, occupying an elevated sta
may prove the cause of calamity and distress to the
state. In the hour of danger, when the lives of
thousands, or the security of a nation may be de
pending on his firmness and intrepidity, he may be
2} seen forsaking his past, and leaving the weak
3} and helpless to the mercy of an invading foe.
1}2 to secure their own lives from meritted destruction,
have been unsparing in the torture and
2 murder of others. History affords too
1 examples of those, who
been under continual suspicion of conspiracy
3 against themselves;
resorted to the most cruel and bloody measures.
3 Who
so apprehensive that all his subjects were conspi
2 ring against his life, that he would not trust his
barber to dress his head, nor admit into his pres
sence his most intimate friends, without a
previous examination? While he was sentencing
to the dungeon and the block every one on
whom his suspicion rested?
1 the conduct of the sanguinary Robespierre, who
1 a short time
6 A man, vain, envious and inexorable. (From his heart,) it would seem that every tender feeling had
been expelled, and every foul passion made wel
3 come to it. His thirst for blood, especially the blood of those whom
he suspected to be his opponents, was insatiable.
out the
1 execution); for
of his heart. Yet this monster in human form,
3 is pronounce by historians, to have been a
coward.
to as being cruel. They are those, who possessing
other necessary qualifications, have not the christian
fortitude, to plant the standard of the Cross in the
dark places of the earth. If christian benevolence
ought ever to be exercised, if courage should ever
be exerted, it is when viewing a world under the
empire of sin. Here indeed is an extensive field
1 for the christian soldier;
1 with boldness, assured
be victorious. But if the fear of persecu
tion; or the dread of death, deter any one from
1 entering this field
1 the worst of
under the dominion of vice and folly, and
yet not (to have courage) to extend to them the
+ hand of deliverance?
measure true, "that cowards are cruel."